“In this world, nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes.” — Benjamin Franklin
As an experienced short-term rental (STR) investor, you’re all too familiar with how taxes can chip away at your cash flow. Rising property values often bring higher taxes, but the real problem comes from how property tax assessments lag behind actual market conditions. This lag can hit you hard, leaving you paying higher taxes even when property values—and possibly rental income—are on the decline.
Let’s break down how this happens, why it’s so crucial for STR investors to stay ahead of the curve, and what you can do to protect your cash flow.
What’s Happening?
As property values rise, local governments reassess properties to adjust tax rates. But here’s where many STR investors get caught—the assessments don’t reflect the current market; they’re based on values from a year or two ago. This “rearview mirror effect” means you could be paying taxes based on past peak values, even if the market has softened.
For STR investors, this lag in assessments can severely impact profits. You could end up stuck with a tax bill based on a time when the market was booming while your rental income and property values have since dropped. This puts unnecessary pressure on your cash flow at a time when costs across the board are rising.
Why This Matters to STR Investors
You’re already balancing increased costs—cleaning fees, utilities, maintenance, and insurance—but property taxes are the single biggest expense that can unexpectedly cut deep into your profits. The critical piece here is that taxes aren’t just rising—they’re doing so on a delay. Your tax bill could be based on last year’s inflated values, even if your STR income has flattened or dipped.
In cooling markets, this lagging tax assessment is especially dangerous. You might be paying top-dollar taxes based on last year’s boom, while your property’s income and value have dropped. It’s a costly scenario that every STR investor needs to watch out for.
Due Diligence: Avoid the Property Tax Trap
To safeguard your STR investment from rising property taxes, here are a few things to consider:
- Contact the Local Tax Assessor: Get an accurate estimate of the current assessed value and projected tax rate to run realistic cash flow projections.
- Review Historical Tax Trends: Look at how taxes have trended over the years. Rising property values typically lead to higher taxes, so plan accordingly.
- Understand Market Conditions: Be cautious in cooling markets—your tax bill may still reflect peak values, which can drain cash flow due to delayed reassessment.
- Know the Reassessment Cycle: Learn how often properties are reassessed (annually or less frequently) to anticipate when your taxes may increase.
- Challenge Your Assessment: If you believe your property’s assessed value is too high, challenge it with evidence such as recent comparable sales. This step is often overlooked but can save you thousands.
- Plan for Future Increases: Build potential tax hikes into your cash flow projections. Don’t rely on the current owner’s tax bill, as reassessment after your purchase could significantly raise your taxes.
Property taxes are inevitable, but they don’t have to drain your profits. Be proactive—get accurate tax assessments, challenge inflated bills, and plan for future increases. By staying ahead of the taxman, you’ll keep your STR cash flow strong and your investment profitable, no matter how the market shift.
About STR Scout
STR Scout is a newsletter crafted to help you enrich your life and grow your wealth globally through strategic investments in Airbnb properties and short-term rentals. We provide tools, resources, and insights tailored for real estate investors, guiding you to make informed decisions. The twice-weekly newsletter delivers property scouting reports, market trends, STR classifieds, and investment news, helping you discover the best opportunities in the global short-term rental market. Join
About STR Homes for Sale
STR Homes for Sale is the top Facebook marketplace for buying and selling Airbnb properties and short-term rentals, boasting 98,700 members. Since 2017, it has connected real estate investors with sellers, offering a free platform to showcase both on and off-market STR properties. With hundreds of thousands of monthly views, this community is a vital resource for those looking to maximize exposure and secure the best deals in the short-term rental market. Join